Latin Mass Society

Chairman's Blog

31/03/2021 - 19:30

Reflections on the CDF statement on blessings of homosexual unions

Last October a film was released which included a clip of Pope Francis saying, of homosexual persons, “they are children of God and have a right to a family. Nobody should be thrown out or made miserable over it. What we have to create is a civil union law. That way they are legally covered.”

BBC Radio 4 asked me to say something about the story when it broke. It turned out that I was to be a “conservative” Catholic voice, to be followed immediately by a “liberal” one, to whit the former Editor of the liberal British Catholic weekly, The Tablet, Catherine Pepinster. The BBC journalists were very excited about the Pope’s statement, and thought it presaged a substantive change of Catholic teaching. I happened to be in Rome at that moment, and from my hotel room I tried to calm them down. The big concession the Pope was making, I said, was the very fact that he had said what he had said. He was not about to change the teaching of the Church about sex outside (heterosexual) marriage. His words were designed, not to ready conservative Catholics for such a change, but to console those who are not reconciled to the teaching.

No doubt to the disappointment of the BBC journalists, Catherine Pepinster agreed with me.

We have been vindicated, now, by a statement from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, setting out the position that the Church does not have the power to bless same-sex unions. The document emphasises that Pope Francis “gave his assent to the publication of the above-mentioned Responsum ad dubium”. It seems that he is in favour of homosexual couples having the legal protections offered by the status of Civil Partnership, but insofar as their relationship (as the CDF says) “involve[s] sexual activity outside of marriage (i.e., outside the indissoluble union of a man and a woman open in itself to the transmission of life)”, then it cannot receive the blessing of the Church. When relationships are blessed, “it is necessary that what is blessed be objectively and positively ordered to receive and express grace, according to the designs of God inscribed in creation, and fully revealed by Christ the Lord.”

Since then Pope Francis has made some qualifying, informal remarks: or possibly not. And the whole media circus goes round again, with rival interpretations and the rest. In the mean time, we’ve just had the bizarre banning of the celebration of (almost all) private Masses in the Vatican basilica. A coincidence, no doubt, but nothing emanating from the Holy See seems to lack a counter-weight, something for the other side of the debate to cheer. Everything is balanced and qualified, obscured by clarifications, and then replaced in the spotlight by the next media-circus act.

This is not just Pope Francis; it is a longer-term feature of the Vatican’s relationship with the media. (Remember Pope Benedict and the condoms?) In order not to go crazy watching the Barque of St Peter apparently tacking wildly in one direction and then another, it is useful to hang on to the distinction Catherine Pepinster and I ended up agreeing one. AsShakespeare’s Henry VIII, about to trash the wretched Cardinal Wolsey, remarks, “words are no deeds.”

As with the issues raised with Amoris Laetitia, one might think that what Pope Francis says is in tension with the teaching, or even flatly incompatible with it, but as with so much over the last fifty years, these words are no deeds. They are intended to change the way people understand the doctrine, or even to distract attention from it, but not to change it. Some of the “pastoral guidelines” on couples living in illicit unions appear to create a situation in which the teaching is relegated to an abstract plane with no connection with reality: but they don’t come out and say the teaching is wrong.

I'm not saying these words are without significance. On the contrary, the resulting pattern of words and actions almost suggests that the teaching of the Church on these fundamental issues is a kind of immovable rock inconveniently in the way of dealing effectively with various delicate pastoral situations, which must therefore somehow be circumvented. It is as if one should say: if onlydivorce and remarriage were possible; if only gay marriage were possible. They aren’t, so let’s give everyone Holy Communion, and ignore the problem. In this way Pope Francis rejects calls to change the teaching, and equally rejects calls to treat the teaching as the life-giving basis of pastoral policy: something to be positively proclaimed and lived by.

The logical conclusion of all this is a picture of the Church labouring under the arbitrary demands of an irrational God, who has to be mollified by keeping certain obscure formulas in the Catechism, but in every other way can be worked around or ignored. This picture, of course, is as contrary to the theological vision of theological conservatives as it is to theological liberals.

Pope Francis' middle way may not be enough to prevent the German Bishops going into schism, and it has not been enough to stop many orthodox pastors and academics (myself included) from protesting, and from criticising Pope Francis, as is set out conveniently in a new book, Defending the Faith, edited by John Lamont. Perhaps Pope Francis will go down in history as the Pope who attempted an impossible balancing-act. It is to be hoped, at least, that his successors learn from this papacy.

Support the Latin Mass Society
30/03/2021 - 19:30

Spring Edition of Gregorius Magnus, the magazine of the FIUV


Cross-posted from the FIUV blog.

The latest edition of Gregorius Magnus is now available, for Spring 2021.

Gregorius Magnus 11 pdf download

It includes a report on the events in Rome last October, in place of the usual Summorum Pontificum Pilgrimage.

It also includes a key passage from the French Bishops' summary report to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on the implementation of Summorum Pontificum, in an English translation published for the first time.

As usual it also includes translations of articles from the quarterly magazines of Una Voce France and Pro Missa Tridentina of Germany, as well as an article from the Latin Mass Society's Mass of Ages, and news and reflections first published here, from Croatia, Romania, and Poland.

It is free to download as a pdf, or to view on the ISSUU website and app for mobile devices.

Support the Latin Mass Society
23/03/2021 - 17:09

Server training in London: back in 2021!

Cross-posted from the blog of the Society of St Tarcisius.

IMG_1486
Server training in St James' Spanish Place, March 2020

I am delighted to announce after a year of enforced inactivity that we will be returning to running our Server Training Days in London.

24th July: St Mary Moorfields, London

(booking page) (info about the venue)

25th September: St James' Spanish Place, London 

(booking page) (info about the venue)

20th November: St James' Spanish Place, London 

(booking page(info about the venue)

These days start at 10:30 am and finish at about 3:30pm.

As usual, there will be a Guild of St Clare Vestment Mending Day running alongside these events: see here for more details.

IMG_1013
Enrollment of new members at St Mary Moorfields in 2019

Support the Latin Mass Society
19/03/2021 - 18:00

Who'd like to talk about Socrates and his friends? Yet more Socratic seminars

I have just concluded the second series of four on-line seminars which I have been leading, on Plato's 'Socratic' or 'early' dialogues, and I'm planning more. The discussions have been stimulating and enjoyable.
So what's this all about?
Socrates is in green up on the left, in profile.

In early January I offered to lead some online seminars on early Socratic dialogues, as a small personal response to the lockdown, and (almost to my surprise) this has actually happened. 

These dialogues are uniquely suited to stimulating discussion among people who don't necessarily already have philosophical training: indeed, it seems very probable that this is the point of them. They introduce us to the thought-world of ancient Athens, and to the methods of philosophy: careful argumentation, exposing hidden assumptions and logical fallacies, all in the context of the personal dynamics of the dialogue format, which adds another layer of interest to these works.
Nothing comes without a background, but the background here is more manageable than that of pretty well any other texts which come to mind. For these, I've been putting together a single page of information about the cultural and historical background to each dialogue, and not asking students to do any other reading apart from the text itself. The dialogues themselves are pretty short (though they vary). So these hour-long seminars don't require a huge amount of preparation.
Having done eight dialogues, including the shorter ones, I am, however, now getting to the point that somewhat longer and more complex texts remain, among those regarded as 'Socratic' dialogues. My selection for the next four seminars, therefore, makes sense for those who have done one or other of the preceding series. For those coming to this fresh, I shall be returning to the first series, which serves as a good introduction to the genre.
So those interested can choose between these two options:
Series 1: recommended for beginners
Euthyphro; Ion; Laches; Lysis.
Series 3: recommended for those who have done some before
Hippias Major; Meno; Euthydemus; Clitophon & Theages.
I expect to start these in the week beginning 5th April: those interested will take part in a Doodle poll to choose mutually convenient times. I've already had participants from Seattle, Chile, and South Africa!
If you are looking at this and wondering if it's going to make any sense to you, go and read Euthyphro and ask yourself if you'd like to talk about it with others.
More details, including prices, here.
Support the Latin Mass Society
19/03/2021 - 11:59

New Podcast, with Dr Jules Gomes

Iota Unum Podcasts

Coming Home to Rome: Dr Jules Gomes talks to Joseph Shaw 

You can hear the podcast on Spotify and other platforms - here's the link to Podbean.

Dr. Jules Gomes, B.A., B.D., M.Th., Ph.D. (Cantab) is Rome Correspondent for Church Militant: author page here.

He is a journalist, academic and editor of the Rebel Priest blog.

He came home to the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church on January 5, 2020.

Support the Latin Mass Society
19/03/2021 - 10:00

LMS Residential Latin and Greek Course, August: booking open

Book now for a week's intensive Latin, aimed at the Latin of the Church's ancient liturgy, or - new for this year - the Greek of the New Testament.

Dates: Monday 16th August - Saturday 21st August
Place: Savio House, a Catholic Retreat Centre run by the Salesians.
Ingersley Rd, Bollington, Macclesfield SK10 5RW (link to map)
Tutors: in Latin, Fr John Hunwicke and Fr Richard Bailey (Cong. Orat.)
In Greek, Mathew Spencer.

Savio House is an attractive 18th century house with lovely grounds on the edge of the Peak District. The accommodation is fairly basic but you can stay nearby if you prefer. 
There will be the Traditional Mass every day. 
Priests and seminarians get a 50% discount in the Latin course, and it is very good value for everyone.
Latin will be for beginners and 'intermediate' students; Greek is also pitched at an early stage, though there is an online course offered by Matthew Spencer for those who need a run-up.
You can get up there by car or train; the course will be unthreatening for beginners and your toil will be relived by the countryside, the company, and the Holy Mass.
Priests attending will of course be able to celebrate Mass in whatever Rite they prefer. Savio House has a chapel and we'll work out how to accommodate everyone.
Our courses have had excellent feedback over the years, and having lost a year to COVID don't miss this opportunity to polish up your Latin or New Testament Greek!
IMG_3900
Fr Hunwicke with students at the Latin Course in a previous venue.

Hear some testimonials!


'I cannot thank you enough for organising this course.'

'I greatly enjoyed the course, in particular the inspirational teaching of Fr John with his deep understanding of Latin, Greek and the long history of the Roman Rite. I found the level challenging, but not overwhelming—just right for me.'

'I’ve been twice to the course now and enjoyed it, I convinced another seminarian to join me this year. I will probably come back next year…'

'Covering an ambitious syllabus did satisfy me, because by the end I did at least have a clear idea of what it is I need to learn; and of course during the week I did actually learn/relearn a great deal of basic grammar and vocabulary.'

Support the Latin Mass Society
17/03/2021 - 17:35

Feminists attack feminists over prostitution

My latest on LifeSiteNews.

To mark International Women’s Day, a feminist group called “Collective for the Abolition of Pornography & Prostitution” conducted a small demonstration in a famous Parisian square, the Place de la Republique. They were attacked, ironically, by a rival gang of feminists, who chanted abuse, pulled down their banners, tried to spray paint their eyes, and made death-threats.

The second group was pro-prostitution, a position which has achieved dominance in the feminism of much of the English-speaking world, but less so elsewhere. Intriguingly, they accused the anti-prostitution group as being “[t]rans-exclusionary”: that is, of not wanting to say that biological males who identify as women are really women. Trans issues were not part of the original protest at all, so this was a matter of the association of ideas on the part of the pro-prostitution group.

Support the Latin Mass Society
16/03/2021 - 09:49

LMS Walsingham Pilgrimage: booking open, early bird discount: 26-30 Aug

IMG_9752

Sign up before Easter Sunday and get 10% off! More info and booking here.
Non-members can join the Latin Mass Society while booking and get the members' discount: from anywhere in the world.
The dates are 26-30th August, Thursday evening in Ely to Sunday afternoon in Walsingham. (There's an extra Mass on Monday for those who've stayed the night in the area.)
The LMS Walking Pilgrimage to Walsingham is a fantastic experience. Not as grueling as the Chartres Pilgrimage in terms of daily distance, and also pretty flat, it is still a very serious walk over three days with singing, praying, spiritual talks from our chaplains, and the Traditional Mass.
Our singing is led by our wonderful cantors - there is one assigned to each chapter - and we have freshly-made hot evening meals thanks to our superb catering team. And porridge for breakfast!
IMG_9957

Follow in the footsteps of England's kings, peasants, sinners and saints: come to Walsingham, and do it the hard way, on foot!
IMG_9918

 

Support the Latin Mass Society
15/03/2021 - 14:55

November Sewing Retreat: Booking open

IMG_1365

The Sewing Retreats of the Guild of St Clare (affiliated to the Latin Mass Society) are always booked out and this autumn's event will be the first after two were knocked out by Covid. Don't delay booking your place!
The retreat giver will be Fr Timothy Finigan.
The dates are 12th-14th November 2021
Venue: the Guesthouse at Douai Abbey in Berkshire.
Come and help make or mend vestments, all skill-levels catered for (honestly!), with Fr Finigan's spiritual conferences and daily Traditional Masses.

IMG_8727

Further ahead, the booking page is open for business for the next Sewing Retreat after that: Spring 2022. 

Retreat giver Fr Stephen Morrison OPraem.

Dates: 4th to 6th February 2022.
Venue: the Guesthouse of Douai Abbey in Berkshire.

IMG_8514

Photos from various Guild events; the last being Fr Edward van den Burgh celebrating Mass for the Sewing Retreat in the previous venue, the Carmelite Retreat Centre at Boars Hill outside Oxford.
Support the Latin Mass Society
13/03/2021 - 17:36

Private Masses in St Peter's: who's in the cross-hairs?

IMG_9070
Private Masses before a 'First Mass' of a newly ordained priest
(Fr William Barker FSSP) in Bavaria, in a church near Wigratzbad.
I was at school next to a vast church with masses of unused side-altars, and they are an apt symbol of the changes which followed the Second Vatican Council. Why would a priest wish to celebrate Mass on a day when he has no public Mass to say? Why bother? Or else, why not tag along with a crowd of priests putting on a concelebrated Mass, so he can tick the box saying he's attended the community's 'conventual' Mass and the box saying he's celebrated, both at once?

The answer is: out of devotion. Because priests can celebrate Mass (almost) every day, pastoral need is not the only reason why they might want to do so. This devotion will very often be fed more effectively at a 'private' Mass sine populo, than a concelebrated Mass with a crowd of other clergy. 
This is without saying anything of the, ahem, controversial theology of concelebration, a concept which came more or less out of nowhere in Vatican II. And no, newly ordained priests don't concelebrate with the ordaining bishop in the modern sense, in the EF: their ritual concelebration is not intended to be sacramentally efficacious. They follow the words of the Canon in a Missal with the help of another priest, in a charming ritualised lesson, not in an attempt to say Mass 'with the bishop'.

IMG_1204
Private Masses at an LMS Priest-Training
Conference at Prior Park, Bath
The war on private Masses, which has been waged by vindictive liberal sacristans, Cathedral administrators, and the like over the decades, has now come to St Peter's, where the practice of a millennium has apparantly been brought to a halt by the stroke of a pen. No more 'individual celebrations' will be allowed - except for four each morning in the EF.
That seems like a puzzling qualification. If the 'conservative Novus Ordo' option of celebrating Mass without the people is to be banned from the Basilica, it seems surprising that provision, however inadequate, is being made for the celebration of the Traditional Mass.
Part of the answer may be how at odds with Canon law the powers-that-be are comfortable with being. Canons 902 says:
'They [sc. priests] are completely free to celebrate the Eucharist individually, however, but not while a concelebration is taking place in the same church or oratory.'
But that is generally speaking exactly what has been happening in St Peter's: multiple simultaneous celebrations, very often including concelebrations in one of the larger chapels.
Pressing this provision is unreasonable in St Peter's, in my view, for several reasons: one being that a concelebration happening in (say) St Joseph's Chapel (the big chapel in the north transcept) is invisible and inaudible from most of the rest of the Upper Basilica, let alone the crypt, and another being that these larger celebrations are frequently in the language of visitors to Rome, not necessarily shared by priests wishing to say a private Mass. Again, there is the question of the application of Canon 903, allowing priests to celebrate Mass in churches on demand. Nevertheless, it may be that this Canon is providing the faceless functionary behind this strange decree with some kind of cover.
Unilaterally suspending Summorum Pontificum on the other hand may be thought to be a bit much. Rather than to ban the EF- since it can't be concelebrated - they have contented themselves with restricting it to four Masses a day in a tiny chapel in the crypt.
IMG_7224
A private Mass at another LMS Priest Training Conference, at Belmont Abbey.

 

It seems a fair assumption that those who are motivated to stamp out individual celebrations in the OF probably aren't very keen on the EF, but this is a striking result all the same. From now on (while this decree is in force), the only way of celebrating an individual Mass in St Peter's will be by doing so in the EF. The Traditional Mass, thanks to having its own rules, has actually escaped, at least in a limited way, the effects of this decree.
I'm not saying that the paranoia of traditional Catholics is not generally justified, but on this occasion I don't think the Traditional Mass is what this decree has in its sights. What I see here is part of the same pattern with Pope Francis' condemnation of the Reform of the Reform, his slapping down Cardinal Sarah on the subject of celebration ad orientem, and his changes to Canon law allowing the foot-washing of females on Holy Thursday. It is the 'conservative Novus Ordo' which is the target. It is that which represents the prime threat to the progressive project, in the view of the people behind these initiatives. It is that which must be suppressed.
We Catholics attached to the EF need to remind ourselves every now and then how utterly insignificant the Traditional Mass is around the world, as far as most Catholics are concerned. Perhaps a good parallel would be the liturgical adaptations allowed to the Neo-Catechumenate: occasionally a matter requiring some attention, but for most practical purposes of a level of importance indistinguishable from zero.
Long may our opponents continue to take this view. For the 'conservative Novus Ordo' folk, however, I'm afraid the party's over.
Support the Latin Mass Society

Charity web design by Turtlereality

© LMS 2016 | Registered Charity Number: 248388 | Terms & Conditions

Latin Mass Society, 9 Mallow Street, London EC1Y 8RQ | 020 7404 7284 | [email protected]

randomdiss